Article
Amir Nazemi1,*
1Department of Futures Studies, National Research Institute for Science Policy (NRISP), Tehran, Iran
*Corresponding author: Amir Nazemi, Department of Futures Studies, National Research Institute for Science Policy (NRISP), Tehran, Iran. Email: amirnazemy@gmail.com. ORCID: 0000-0002-9096-510X
Abstract
Causal Layered Analysis diagnoses myth, and rightly so: naming a story makes it renegotiable. But diagnosis has a tense, and CLA practice has standardized the present one. The macrohistorical inheritance CLA claims, from Sarkar’s cycle to Sorokin’s pendulum to Thompson’s mythopoetics, assumes that deep cultural codes transform. Four reworkings of the Persian Khosrow and Shirin narrative at Iranian turning points, with Arthurian, Indian epic, and Faustian parallels, yield a four-stage account of adaptive mythic transformation: tension, supply, selection, stabilization. A horizon-dependent rule follows. Short-range foresight may diagnose synchronically; long-range foresight must diagnose diachronically.
Keywords
Causal layered analysis, Macrohistory, Myth and metaphor, Temporal horizon, Mythic transformation
1. Introduction
In 1998 Sohail Inayatullah published two papers in Futures. The better known introduced Causal Layered Analysis, which reads any present condition on four nested levels: the litany of surface events, the systemic causes behind them, the worldview that renders those systems intelligible, and the myth and metaphor that hold worldviews emotionally in place (Inayatullah, 1998a). The other surveyed macrohistory as the study of “meta patterns of change” across time, space, and episteme (Inayatullah, 1998b), continuing the comparative project of Macrohistory and Macrohistorians (Galtung & Inayatullah, 1997). The two papers are halves of one movement: CLA was, in Inayatullah’s later account, the practical translation of macrohistorical insight for organizations that could not use civilizational theory directly (Inayatullah et al., 2022). The bibliometric record preserves the lineage layer by layer. The systemic layer draws on Galtung, the worldview layer on Foucault, and the myth and metaphor layer on William Irwin Thompson and Galtung’s civilizational work (Wahab, 2024).
This article begins from a puzzle in that inheritance. Macrohistory is definitionally the study of how deep cultural structures change. Sarkar’s social cycle turns because the collective psychology of an age exhausts itself; Sorokin’s pendulum swings when a dominant mentality becomes overripe; Thompson reads civilizational transition through the transformation of mythic material. Yet in the applied CLA literature the fourth layer is handled in a single tense. The analyst descends, names the myth, and stops, a pattern that Wahab’s (2024) mapping of 292 publications confirms. The layer that inherits macrohistory’s mandate is the layer least often studied historically.
It is worth stating precisely what is and is not claimed. The fourth layer is diagnostic, and it must be. One cannot change what has not been identified, and the act of naming a myth is itself a powerful intervention, since a story dragged into the light ceases to be unquestioned truth and becomes a version of truth that can be renegotiated. The pivot from diagnosis to development turns on a question that cannot be asked before the diagnosis has been made: does this story serve the future we say we want? Nothing in the argument below disputes this sequence. The critique is narrower and, precisely for that reason, sharper. A diagnosis is made in a tense, and the tense that CLA practice has silently standardized is the present. A synchronic diagnosis reports what the myth is; a diachronic diagnosis reports where the myth stands, whether freshly stabilized and tightly coupled to its audience or already fraying under a tension its carriers have begun to feel. Both are diagnoses. Only the second tells the practitioner whether the door that naming opens is likely to swing.
The choice between them is not a matter of methodological virtue but of temporal horizon. For the one-to-fifteen-year window of most organizational foresight, myth moves so slowly that treating it as fixed is a defensible simplification. The analogy relied on throughout is conceptual rather than computational: in multi-timescale systems modeling a slow variable may be held as a parameter over a short window and must be endogenized over a long one (Ford, 2018; Li et al., 2023). For long-range work, at the horizon where macrohistory operates, the same simplification suppresses the variable that macrohistorical theory identifies as decisive. Longue durée research treats deep cultural structures as slow-moving but not fixed (Hoyer et al., 2023; Rius-Ulldemolins & Pizzi, 2021), and collective memory scholarship finds foundational narratives refashioned every few generations (Singh & Thakur, 2025; Foroughi, 2020).
Evidence comes from three sources. A critical review of nineteen CLA studies establishes the prevalence of synchronic diagnosis. A hermeneutic-historical study traces four reworkings of the Persian Khosrow and Shirin narrative, each accompanying a recognized turning point in Iranian history. Comparative evidence from the Arthurian, Indian epic, and Faustian traditions then shows that the pattern is not peculiar to Iran.
From this material the article derives a four-stage account of how a myth transforms: foundational tension, alternative supply, competitive selection, and stabilization. The account is offered not as a rival to macrohistory but as its missing micro-mechanism, the process by which a phase change in the social cycle or the sensate–ideational pendulum registers as an actual change in the stories a culture tells. Sarkar and Sorokin describe the rhythm at civilizational scale. The four stages describe what happens inside a single mythic configuration as that rhythm passes through it, and they give the CLA practitioner something operational: a way to locate a named myth in its trajectory rather than merely in the present.
Section 2 reconstructs CLA’s macrohistorical lineage and the limited role Polak’s thesis can bear within it. Sections 3 and 4 present the review and the method, Section 5 the Persian and comparative cases, and Section 6 the four stages. Section 7 states the horizon-dependent rule and takes up the question of agency.
2. Theoretical Framework: CLA, Macrohistory, and the Tense of Diagnosis
2.1 The analytical logic of depth
CLA is a depth hermeneutic rather than a forecasting technique. Inayatullah (1998a) drew on post-structuralist and post-development thought, principally Foucault, Sarkar, and Galtung, to argue that the future is constituted by competing discourses, and that the analyst’s task is to descend through them to the level at which their emotional and narrative force originates. The distinctive claim concerns leverage: the deeper the engagement, the more durable the change. In the six pillars framework (Inayatullah, 2008), deepening the future is a precondition for transforming it. The layers are not inert strata but mutually reinforcing habits. Left undisturbed, each stabilizes the others, which is why surfacing the deepest one has disproportionate effect.
2.2 The fourth layer in the methodological literature
MacGill (2015) offers the most extensive theoretical account of layer four, showing how embodied metaphors coalesce into myths and how worldviews are constituted by their arrangement. That account is structural and synchronic. Bussey (2014) frames CLA as a “method of the multiple,” a process theory of the method rather than of the myths. Watson (2009) comes closest to the present argument, locating the fourth layer on the “timescale of macrohistory” without carrying that scale into an empirical study. Haigh (2016) records the practical corollary: analysts find layer four the hardest to work with, in part because they lack a tractable account of how it moves.
2.3 CLA 2.0, 3.0, and the compression of mythic time
The transformative program reframed metaphor from descriptive endpoint to designable target. CLA 2.0 (Inayatullah & Milojević, 2015) and narrative foresight (Milojević & Inayatullah, 2015) invite practitioners to write alternative metaphors, and Spencer and Salvatico (2015) supply a story re-imagining procedure. The Futures metaphor special issue (Inayatullah et al., 2016) marked the approach’s high point, Cowart (2022) added situational sensitivity, and Connolly (2025) extended re-storying to conspiracy narratives. This work is right that myths can change and that naming them is the gateway. Its limitation is temporal. Change is enacted within a workshop or a strategy cycle, whereas the transformations macrohistory studies unfold across generations. The program has compressed civilizational time into project time.
2.4 Macrohistory: the other half of the 1998 project
The resources for decompressing it are already in CLA’s own lineage. Sarkar’s social cycle turns collective psychology through four archetypes, the worker, the warrior, the intellectual, and the acquisitive, each phase generating the exhaustion that moves the wheel on. Inayatullah treats the cycle as one of the principal macrohistorical templates and devoted a monograph to situating it as an episteme rather than a mere periodization (Inayatullah, 1998b, 2002). What matters here is that in Sarkar’s account each phase carries its own characteristic mythic and symbolic repertoire. A turn of the cycle is not merely a change of ruling group but a change in the stories through which a society understands worth, order, and destiny.
Sorokin’s pendulum makes the same point in a different idiom, and with a fuller apparatus. His Social and Cultural Dynamics (1937–1941/2017) treats culture as an integrated whole oscillating between ideational, idealistic, and sensate orientations. These are shifts not in institutions alone but in meaning systems: in what a civilization takes reality to be, spiritual or sensory. Transitions occur when a dominant mentality becomes, in his term, overripe (Zuzánek, 2020; Richard, 2018). Sorokin remains relevant to civilizational-scale analysis even where his specific long-range forecasts failed (Peltonen, 2018; Targowski, 2022). The methodological implication for CLA is direct. If cultural epochs are shifts of dominant meaning system, then layer four is exactly where a Sorokinian transition would first become legible.
William Irwin Thompson is the figure the bibliometric record identifies as a direct influence on layer four (Wahab, 2024). His contribution is not a cyclical model but a mythopoetic account of civilizational transformation, in which myth is the medium through which a culture undergoing disintegration assembles the materials of its successor (Thompson, 1971, 1981; Irwin & Redenius, 1984). A cognate line in the futures literature argues that societies are organized by implicit metaphors and deep images, and that planetary-scale transformation requires innovative myths (Patomäki & Steger, 2010; Rival, 2021).
Taken together, these traditions license a conclusion that the CLA literature has not drawn explicitly: the assumption of mythic mutability is constitutive of the macrohistorical inheritance CLA claims. A method that operationalizes macrohistory but freezes the layer in which macrohistorical change becomes visible has kept the form of the inheritance while suspending its content.
2.5 Polak’s place and its limits
Polak’s thesis that the rise and fall of images of the future precedes or accompanies the rise and fall of cultures (Polak, 1973) is the most frequently invoked bridge between futures studies and civilizational change, and it retains a role here: Polak understood myth as the oldest vehicle of future-imaging. But it cannot bear the full weight of the present argument. Its causal claim is weakly demonstrated, since Polak asserts rather than establishes the relation between images and structural change (Segerstad, 1973), and van der Helm (2005) describes the work as uneven. Its model is idealistic and dialectical rather than cyclical, closer to the tradition of progress than to rise-and-fall macrohistory (Morgan, 2002, 2015), so it sits at an angle to Sarkar and Sorokin rather than summarizing them. Contemporary work also reciprocates his causal arrow: images are shaped by present structures and then feed back into action (Bazzani, 2022; Rindova & Martins, 2021), a loop that Kaboli and Tapio (2017) model at the worldview layer in the only published study linking Polak to CLA. Polak is therefore retained as a statement of why the mythic layer matters, not as the mechanism by which it moves; that mechanism is sought in macrohistory and specified in Section 6. The historical claim below is accordingly one of meaningful accompaniment, without assertion of causal direction.
3. Critical Review: The Tense of Diagnosis in Nineteen CLA Studies
3.1 Method of review
Nineteen studies were selected against four criteria. The first is CLA as the primary method. The second is substantial citation within futures studies, indexed by presence in Wahab’s (2024) mapping or by above-median Scopus counts for CLA-tagged papers. The third is coverage of the principal venues across all three decades: Journal of Futures Studies, Futures, Foresight, European Journal of Futures Research, Futures & Foresight Science, and Technological Forecasting and Social Change. The fourth is inclusion of the method’s restatements and of the principal theoretical treatments of layer four. Each study was coded for the tense of its fourth-layer diagnosis: synchronic, meaning the myth of a present moment, or diachronic, meaning the myth situated in a trajectory.
3.2 Synchronic diagnosis as the norm
In most empirical work the fourth layer is diagnosed and closed in the present tense. Bishop and Dzidic (2014) and Breen et al. (2015) formalize CLA as layered thematic analysis whose deepest step identifies existing myths at a single moment. Talebian and Talebian (2018) name “Educating the Populace” as the deepest myth of Iranian media politics without situating it in the country’s twentieth-century trajectory. Ghahfarokhi et al. (2018), Biglari et al. (2022), Botta (2019), and Kaboli and Tapio (2017) likewise surface operative myths at one time-slice, and recent applications preserve the tense (Camrass, 2022; Scolozzi & Villa, 2025; Khouzani et al., 2024; Ngo et al., 2025; Van Hoa Tran & Ngo, 2025). Riedy (2008) partially escapes by historicizing the levels of consciousness within which myths operate, but the myth itself remains a mapped depth rather than a tracked trajectory.
None of this is a failure of execution. These are careful studies, and in each the naming of the myth does the interventionist work described in Section 1. The observation is only that the diagnosis is uniformly present-tense, and that nothing in the method as codified prompts the analyst to ask where the named myth stands in its own history.
3.3 The transformative branch and project time
The transformative branch treats myth as changeable and understands that diagnosis opens onto development. It includes CLA 2.0 (Inayatullah & Milojević, 2015), narrative foresight (Milojević & Inayatullah, 2015), story re-imagining (Spencer & Salvatico, 2015), shared-narrative construction (Ketonen-Oksi, 2018), situational metaphor (Cowart, 2022), and the systems-coupled analysis of Kim et al. (2021). Its limitation is that the developmental move is enacted within project time. None of these studies models a mythic change that occurred without a practitioner in the room, which is the only kind macrohistory records.
3.4 Comparative synthesis
Table 1 sorts the studies by the tense of their fourth-layer diagnosis. The two groups differ on whether myth can be changed; they agree, tacitly, on when it is examined.
Table 1: Nineteen CLA studies by the tense of their fourth-layer diagnosis.
| Study (Author, Year; Venue) | Domain | Tense of layer-4 diagnosis | Brief description |
|---|---|---|---|
| (a) Synchronic diagnosis | |||
| Inayatullah (1998a); Futures | Foundational theory | Synchronic; macrohistorical mandate | Introduces layer four; the companion macrohistory paper supplies the diachronic frame not carried into practice. |
| Watson (2009); Sociol Res Online | Youth identity | Synchronic; macrohistorical framing | Names the macrohistorical timescale without an empirical study of mythic change. |
| Bishop & Dzidic (2014); Am J Community Psychol | Wicked problems | Synchronic | Four-step framework; myths identified at a single moment. |
| Bussey (2014); Foresight & STI Governance | Meta-methodology | Process theory of method, not of myth | CLA as method of the multiple; plurality of knowledge rather than myth dynamics. |
| Breen et al. (2015); Oxford handbook chapter | Methodological exposition | Synchronic | CLA as layered thematic analysis; myths as archetypes to surface. |
| MacGill (2015); J Futures Studies | Theory of layer 4 | Structural-synchronic | Deepest account of metaphor-to-myth formation; no diachronic dimension. |
| Riedy (2008); Futures | CLA + integral theory | Synchronic-extended | Historicizes levels of consciousness; myth itself remains present-tense. |
| Kaboli & Tapio (2017); Futures | Images of the future | Synchronic; Polak link | Only explicit Polak–CLA bridge; operates at worldview layer, present tense. |
| Talebian & Talebian (2018); Eur J Futures Res | Iranian media politics | Synchronic | Names deepest myth without situating it in a trajectory. |
| Biglari et al. (2022); Futures | Elite migration | Synchronic | Extracts underlying myths without historical situation. |
| Camrass (2022); Foresight | Regenerative urbanism | Synchronic | Myth and worldview as present-tense paradigm contrast. |
| Scolozzi & Villa (2025); Geographies | Alpine development | Synchronic | Three co-existing metaphors mapped in the present. |
| (b) Developmental intervention within project time | |||
| Inayatullah & Milojević (2015); CLA 2.0 | Method reformulation | Present-tense intervention | Narrative-change practice; developmental move enacted at a single time-point. |
| Cowart (2022); J Futures Studies | Metaphor refinement | Present-tense, context-sensitive | Situational metaphor; still within a single decision moment. |
| Connolly (2025); World Futures | Conspiracy narratives | Present-tense intervention | Active re-storying toward inclusive futures. |
| Milojević & Inayatullah (2015); Futures | Narrative foresight | Present-tense, design-oriented | Methodology for writing alternative narratives at a single moment. |
| Spencer & Salvatico (2015); CLA 2.0 chapter | Story re-imagining | Present-tense intervention | Workshop procedure for re-imagining stories. |
| Ketonen-Oksi (2018); Eur J Futures Res | Service ecosystems | Present-tense intervention | Shared narratives constructed deliberately in a workshop setting. |
| Kim et al. (2021); Technol Forecast Soc Change | Automotive retail | Present-tense, systems-coupled | CLA with causal loop diagrams; deep assumptions linked to business-model change. |
Note. Author’s compilation from the cited studies. Group (a) diagnoses the myth of a present moment; group (b) treats myth as changeable but enacts that change within project time.
4. Method
The primary case is a four-moment hermeneutic-historical study. The reworkings are read in order of composition and in their audience contexts, for changes in narrative framing, characterization, and the operative model of love and legitimacy. The Khosrow and Shirin narrative was selected on four grounds. It is central to the Persianate world, which makes changes in its telling more than authorial idiosyncrasy (Meisami, 1987; Davis, 2024). It exists in four substantial reworkings across genres and centuries. It turns on a compact set of recurring elements, the king, the princess, and the stonemason, which permits precise comparison. And it has a developed secondary literature against which claims can be checked (Talattof, 1997; Bürgel, 1988; Losensky, 2003; Khaleghi-Motlagh, 2010; Sarhaddi, 2020; Khalegdadi et al., 2025). Section 5.5 adds three comparative traditions to test whether the pattern is particular to Iran.
Three guardrails address the standard objections to claims of historical accompaniment. The first concerns post-hoc periodization, since period labels are heuristic orientations rather than self-evident causal units (Aleksić, 2021); the turning points invoked here are independently recognized in the historiography and were not constructed for this argument. The second concerns over-statement of rupture. Persian literary historiography has been criticized for nationalist master-narratives that exaggerate breaks, and strong continuity runs between late Safavid and post-Safavid poetics (Schwartz, 2020; Jabbari, 2022), so the analysis registers continuity explicitly: every reworking preserves the mythic core it reconfigures. The third concerns conflating co-occurrence with causation, and the claim is therefore limited to meaningful accompaniment, consistent with reciprocal models of narrative and social change (Bazzani, 2022; Hase, 2021). Two limitations remain: the study works from editions and secondary scholarship rather than quantitative content analysis, and the tempo estimates in Section 7 are indicative.
5. Four Reworkings at Four Turning Points
5.1 From epic frame to romance: Ferdowsi and Nezami
Ferdowsi’s Shahnameh (c. 1010) belongs to the consolidation of New Persian as a literary and inter-regional language, the linguistic turning point of the Samanid and early Ghaznavid period (Lazard, 1975). The poem is itself the monument of that transition, carrying pre-Islamic narrative material into a new linguistic vessel. Within it, Khosrow Parviz and Shirin form an episode of dynastic epic. Shirin figures in the king’s biography rather than as a center of narrative attention, and the register is heroic (Khaleghi-Motlagh, 2010; Davis, 2024). The operative myth is kingship as the encompassing frame, with love among its appurtenances.
Nezami’s Khosrow o Shirin (1180) belongs to the twelfth-century Iranian dynastic revival, in which Seljuk and Atabeg courts governed through revived Iranian institutions and idioms and sustained a competitive culture of literary patronage (Meisami, 1987). Three shifts define the reworking. Shirin becomes an active subject, an Armenian princess with her own court, whose acceptance of Khosrow is conditional on his moral formation (Talattof, 1997; Bürgel, 1988). Farhad the stonemason enters as moral counter-figure, transforming love “from narrative content into a realm of feeling and meaning” (Khalegdadi et al., 2025; Sarhaddi, 2020). And the political space becomes federated, with legitimacy mediated by alliance and character rather than by descent alone. The myth becomes love as a relation between subjects rather than an attribute of kingship. The same nominal story now carries a different myth.
5.2 From court to craftsman: Vahshi Bafqi and the Qajar completions
Vahshi Bafqi (d. 1583) began Farhad o Shirin under the Safavid state. That state was the first comprehensive Iranian polity after Islam, with Twelver Shi’ism as its religion, and the historiography treats it as a major Persianate reorganization rather than stylistic drift (Ahmadi, 2020; Schwartz, 2020). The change of title is diagnostic. Where Nezami’s poem is named for king and princess, the Safavid-era poem is named for the stonemason. Shirin’s love, ambivalent between suitors in Nezami, becomes reciprocal with Farhad, and the register moves toward interiority and the ethics of devotion. The myth shifts to worth established through devotion rather than station.
The fourth moment is easily misread as philological tidying. Vahshi’s poem, unfinished at his death, was completed by Vesal Shirazi (d. 1846) and continued by Saber Kermani later in the nineteenth century. But the decision of Qajar-era poets, after two and a half centuries, to return to this poem and finish it is an act of mythic selection, a statement about which configuration the culture wished to stabilize. The context is the late Qajar transformation: European contact, print culture, reform debates, and the ferment issuing in the Constitutional Revolution of 1906, a period the scholarship treats as a refashioning of Persianate pasts for new national presents (Schwartz, 2020; Ahmadi, 2020). The completions consolidate the Farhad-centered, mutual, time-bound configuration in which the romance entered modern Iranian consciousness: mutual love between equals as the image of the highest human bond.
5.3 The pattern
Table 2 aligns the four reworkings with their accompanying turning points. Each involved simultaneous transformation in language, polity, religion, or external relations, and each reworking reconfigured the deepest layer while preserving the recognizable core.
Table 2: Four reworkings of Khosrow and Shirin and their accompanying turning points.
| Reworking | Accompanying turning point | Dimension of structural change | Reconfigured myth (layer 4) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ferdowsi, c. 1010 | Consolidation of New Persian (Samanid/Ghaznavid) | Language: Middle to New Persian as literary and inter-regional medium | Kingship as encompassing frame; love as royal appurtenance |
| Nezami, 1180 | Iranian dynastic revival (Seljuk–Atabeg) | Polity: rule through revived Iranian institutions; multi-court legitimacy | Love as a relation between subjects; legitimacy morally earned |
| Vahshi Bafqi, 16th c. | Safavid state | Religion and polity: first comprehensive post-Islamic Iranian state; Shi’ism as state religion | Worth through devotion rather than station; the craftsman at the center |
| Vesal Shirazi & Saber Kermani, 19th c. | Late Qajar transformation; run-up to the Constitutional Revolution | External relations and ideas: European contact, print culture, proto-national refashioning | Stabilization: mutual love between equals as the highest human bond |
Note. Author’s synthesis; period characterizations follow Lazard (1975), Meisami (1987), Ahmadi (2020), Schwartz (2020), and Jabbari (2022).
5.4 The analyst of 1150: a thought experiment
Consider an analyst performing a CLA in 1150, three decades before Nezami. They would correctly name the operative myth as kingship-with-consort and report it as the culture’s deep structure. The naming would be accurate and, on the account defended in Section 1, genuinely interventionist. What it would not register is that the myth stood within a generation of losing its grip, or that the reconfiguration about to displace it would organize the tradition for eight centuries. The error lies not in the layers but in the tense. Nothing in the method prompts the question that mattered: where in its trajectory does this myth stand?
5.5 Beyond Iran: three comparative traditions
If the pattern were peculiar to Persian literary history it would carry little methodological weight. Reception scholarship documents the same shape elsewhere.
The Arthurian legend passes from Geoffrey of Monmouth’s chronicle, which helped raise Arthur into an instrument of emergent national identity, through Chrétien’s turn toward interiority and courtly relation. It arrives at Tennyson’s Victorian reinvention, in which the material was recoded around monarchy, gender, childhood, and moral order (Wallis, 2022; Mancoff, 1995; Bryden, 2020). The legend was not merely revived at each juncture but reinvented for a changed social formation.
The Indian epics show the longest and most plural version of the pattern. Ruling elites in the Deccan appropriated Rāmāyaṇa and Mahābhārata material to construct kingship, and the political use of the epics shifted over centuries, from the image of the perfect monarch toward the conferral of religious identity (Sharma, 2026). The plasticity continues into the present. The epics have been reworked to the point of counter-narrative, including anti-Rāmāyaṇas, in answer to the needs of changing regional, religious, and political constituencies, and contemporary film adaptations recruit the material for current nationalist projects (Vanina, 2022; Mukherjee, 2025).
The Faust legend offers the most explicitly periodized case. It condenses in sixteenth-century German Protestant culture around transgression, obedience, and shifting religious authority (Laan & Weeks, 2013). It then becomes the hedonist of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century popular theater, before being remade under Enlightenment and Counter-Enlightenment pressure into Faust the scientist, with knowledge and its ethical dangers at the center (Bogomolov, 2025). Later it is read as the drama of modernity and capitalism, and recruited by Soviet criticism into a teleology of class struggle (Fernández-Figares, 2019; Bregadze, 2023). Homeric epic supplies a looser fourth instance (Tomasso, 2023; Erll, 2019).
The comparison establishes a bounded claim rather than a law. In several major traditions a single canonical narrative is successively reworked under changing political, confessional, and media formations, behaving as a malleable repertoire rather than a constant. The evidence does not yet support a quantitative demonstration that reworkings cluster at disruptions (see Section 6.3).
6. Four Stages of Mythic Transformation
6.1 Four stages
The cases display a recurring structure, set out here as four stages. Stage 1, foundational tension: the reigning configuration is increasingly experienced as inadequate to the social and emotional realities of its audience. This is not yet a crisis of belief but a loss of fit, the condition Sorokin describes as a mentality becoming overripe. Stage 2, alternative supply: cultural producers offer reconfigured versions, preserving enough to be recognizable and changing enough to address the felt inadequacy, as with Nezami’s agentive Shirin, Vahshi’s craftsman, and Faust remade as scientist. Stage 3, competitive selection: alternatives circulate, are taken up or rejected, imitated and contested, and adjusted in reception. Stage 4, stabilization: a reconfiguration settles as the new default, and earlier versions persist in memory without their former emotive force, the work performed for the Farhad-centered configuration by the Qajar completions. Many transformations stall before Stage 4, and a stall is as diagnostic as a completion.
6.2 The stages as the micro-mechanism of macrohistorical change
The account does not rival macrohistory; it supplies a level of description that macrohistory leaves implicit. Sarkar’s cycle and Sorokin’s pendulum specify the rhythm of civilizational change and the sequence of dominant mentalities. Neither specifies how a particular story changes as that rhythm passes through it. The four stages describe exactly that: the internal career of one mythic configuration during a phase transition. The relation is one of nesting rather than competition. A Sorokinian shift from a sensate to a more ideational orientation would be visible, at the level of a single narrative, as an accumulation of foundational tension, a supply of reconfigurations weighted toward the incoming mentality, a period of contested selection, and eventual stabilization. Thompson’s account of myth as the medium through which a disintegrating culture assembles its successor (Thompson, 1971, 1981) is, on this reading, a description of Stages 2 and 3 at civilizational scale.
Two consequences follow. Macrohistorical diagnosis gains an empirical handle: rather than assigning a civilization to a phase by broad cultural impression, the analyst can ask which stage its central narratives occupy. And CLA gains what Section 1 identified as missing, a way to make the fourth-layer diagnosis diachronic without abandoning its diagnostic character. Naming the myth remains the gateway; the stages add the tense.
6.3 Position against adjacent frameworks, and boundary conditions
The nearest non-macrohistorical cognate is cultural evolution (Boyd & Richerson, 2005; Henrich et al., 2008), in which variants circulate, audiences exercise content-sensitive evaluation, and stabilization constitutes the new default. The present account differs in being staged rather than aggregate, and narrative-hermeneutic rather than replicator-theoretic, since its unit is the mythic configuration as a meaningful whole. Structural narratology is complementary, identifying the recurring elements whose changing arrangement the stages track (Sarhaddi, 2020). Archetypal continuity is accommodated rather than opposed. The king–princess–craftsman triangle persists across all four Persian moments, as the hero and the pact persist across Arthur and Faust, and the claim here concerns the structured, historically consequential variation of that persisting core (Kawai et al., 2022).
Four limits require statement. First, the account addresses cultural-internal dynamics, and a complete treatment must add the institutional conditions under which alternatives circulate, since structural constraint limits narrative uptake (Harding et al., 2017; Vaara et al., 2016). In the Persian case these include patronage, religious authority, and the economy of literary production. Second, “audience-driven” must be read carefully. Audiences select among offerings produced by poets and patrons embedded in networks that orchestrate narrative practice over decades (Di Stefano & Dalpiaz, 2018), so endogenous here means internal to the cultural system rather than audience-only. Third, the unit “myth” must be bounded before its trajectory can be tracked. Fourth, the evidence is qualitative and reception-historical, so the account’s status is that of a well-supported hypothesis rather than a measured regularity.
7. Temporal Horizon, Diagnostic Tense, and Agency
7.1 Myth as a slow variable
The Persian intervals span roughly 170 to 400 years, and the Faustian and Arthurian sequences are comparable. These are order-of-magnitude observations from reception history, not calibrated rates; no such rates exist for mythic change. They are sufficient, however, to place myth among the slowest variables foresight encounters. Three bodies of work point the same way. Foundational narratives are refashioned every few generations (Singh & Thakur, 2025). Orchestrated narrative change requires decades (Di Stefano & Dalpiaz, 2018). And the longue durée literature treats deep cultural structures as persistent but evolving (Hoyer et al., 2023; Rius-Ulldemolins & Pizzi, 2021; Silva et al., 2022). Systems modeling supplies the template, by analogy rather than by formal adoption. Sound practice separates timescales, holding slow variables as parameters over short windows and endogenizing them over long ones, since ignoring cross-timescale coupling misleads (Ford, 2018; Li et al., 2023). The argument borrows the logic of that distinction, not its mathematics. Foresight already behaves this way implicitly (O’Mahony et al., 2023; Spennemann, 2023), without having applied the distinction to layer four.
7.2 A horizon-dependent rule
The rule proposed is therefore twofold. For short- and medium-range foresight, at horizons of roughly fifteen years or less, synchronic diagnosis is a defensible simplification: the myth will almost certainly not complete a transformation within the study window, and the analytic cost of endogenizing it exceeds the benefit. This is not the present-tense habit vindicated but licensed knowingly, as an approximation. The practitioner should still record which stage the myth occupies, because the prospects of the developmental move differ sharply between a myth freshly stabilized and one already under tension. For long-range and civilizational foresight, at multi-decadal to centennial horizons and in any macrohistorically framed inquiry, diagnosis must be diachronic. The myth’s current stage is identified, candidate alternative supplies are scanned, and the possibility of reconfiguration is built into the scenario logic. A long-range study that fixes its myths has assumed away the variable its own macrohistorical framing identifies as decisive.
This resolves the review’s puzzle without indicting either camp. The synchronic mainstream is in effect doing short-horizon work and is entitled to its simplification. The transformative branch is right that myths change, but it works in project time, compressing into a workshop what history performs across generations. What is missing in both is the coupling of diagnostic tense to temporal horizon: a fifth step, optional by horizon, in which the named myth is located in time.
7.3 Who holds the agency?
A question follows that the foregoing sharpens rather than settles. If diagnosis opens the door and development means walking through it, then transformation requires agency. Futurists have generally declined to supply that agency, creating instead the spaces in which different sources of it can find one another. Is the problem, then, CLA’s treatment of myth, or the identification of who holds agency for the developmental move?
The horizon rule suggests the two questions are versions of one another. At short horizons agency is identifiable and addressable: a client, a coalition, or a community, present in the room and able to ask whether the named story serves them. At civilizational horizons no such agent exists. No convening body decided that Iranian culture would rethink the relation of love to legitimate rule between the eleventh and nineteenth centuries; agency was distributed across poets, patrons, audiences, and structural pressure, over a timescale longer than any deliberating body persists. Hence the practical force of diachronic diagnosis: at long horizons the practitioner’s leverage lies not in mobilizing an agent but in reading the stage a myth has reached and identifying where alternative supply is emerging. The futurist’s contribution shifts from convening the room to timing the intervention, recognizing which door is, at this moment in a myth’s trajectory, capable of opening.
8. Conclusion
The fourth layer of CLA is diagnostic, and its diagnostic character is not a defect but the condition of everything that follows. Myth is indeed the most stable of the four layers, and that stability is what lets it underwrite change at the levels above it and what makes it mark the limits within which change is available. A myth must be named before it can be questioned, and naming is itself the intervention that turns unquestioned truth into a version of truth. The argument of this article is that a diagnosis is nonetheless made in a tense, and that the tense should be chosen rather than inherited. For short and medium horizons the present tense suffices; for long-range and civilizational work it does not. CLA’s own macrohistorical inheritance is the reason why. From Sarkar’s cycle through Sorokin’s pendulum to Thompson’s mythopoetics, those traditions assume that deep cultural codes transform, and a method that operationalizes them while freezing layer four keeps the form of the inheritance and suspends its content.
Four reworkings of Khosrow and Shirin at four Iranian turning points, corroborated by the Arthurian, Indian, and Faustian sequences, show myths moving with a recurrent structure. That structure arises from the interaction between a society and its myth: as a society’s understanding shifts across spans of centuries, the myth is updated in turn. Four stages specify the movement. Foundational tension arises when a myth’s present configuration ceases to fit the common understanding of its audience. Alternative supply follows, as cultural producers offer reconfigured versions. Competitive selection sets those versions against one another until a newer configuration finds acceptance. Stabilization settles one of them as the default. The sequence is offered as the micro-mechanism of macrohistorical phase change, or what happens inside a story when the cycle turns, and it yields three recommendations. CLA studies should state their temporal horizon, choose their diagnostic tense accordingly, and say when they expect mythic change to become a question about the future rather than a matter of the past. Practitioners in the CLA 2.0 and 3.0 register should locate interventions within the stages, since a metaphor offered against a freshly stabilized myth and one offered amid active tension are different acts with different prospects. And the field should assemble comparative cases across traditions, both to press that question and to test, refine, or replace the account.
The larger implication is one that macrohistory has always implied and CLA has been positioned to operationalize. A society that cannot rethink its myths can only repeat its past. The Iranian tradition rethought its central narrative of love and legitimacy at each of its great structural thresholds. Each rethinking was at once a product of social and historical development, the foundational tension of the first stage, and a condition for shaping a different future rather than an ornament upon it. For a field whose founding wager is that the future can be other than a repetition, the fourth layer is therefore not the fixed floor of analysis. It is the slowest-moving and highest-leverage variable available, and at any horizon long enough to matter civilizationally it must be diagnosed in motion.
Declarations
Acknowledgments: I am grateful to my friend Sarah Helmzadeh for her guidance in reading and working through Nezami’s Khosrow o Shirin.
Funding: This research received no external funding.
Competing interests: The author declares no competing interests.
Data availability: No new data were created or analyzed. All primary sources cited are publicly available.
Use of AI and AI-Assisted Technologies
In accordance with the JFS policy on AI use, the author discloses two AI tools: Consensus (consensus.app) for literature searching, and Claude (Anthropic) for translation from Persian, APA 7 reference formatting, and language editing. Translation was substantial, since the primary sources and much of the secondary scholarship exist only in Persian. All conceptual content, argument, and conclusions are the author’s own; all sources were independently verified, and the author takes full responsibility for the manuscript.
The author wishes to record his appreciation for what these tools make possible beyond this manuscript. They allow researchers in developing societies to take part in human knowledge without being held back by linguistic barriers. Seen in that light, they not only narrow the global gap between scholars seeking a hearing for their research, but also give a wider range of societies the opportunity to make their own contribution to the shaping of collective human knowledge.
References
Ahmadi, W. (2020). Persian literature and modernity: Production and reception. International Journal of Persian Literature, 5(1), 91–102. https://doi.org/10.5325/intejperslite.5.1.0091
Aleksić, S. (2021). Theoretical problems of periodization of literature. Zbornik radova Filozofskog fakulteta u Prištini, 51(3), 43–58. https://doi.org/10.5937/zrffp51-34234
Bazzani, G. (2022). Futures in action: Expectations, imaginaries and narratives of the future. Sociology, 57(2), 382–397. https://doi.org/10.1177/00380385221138010
Biglari, V., Khoshtinat, B., & Hosseini, S. M. (2022). Causal layered analysis of elite migration: A futures-oriented inquiry. Futures, 138, 102932. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2022.102932
Bishop, B. J., & Dzidic, P. L. (2014). Dealing with wicked problems: Conducting a causal layered analysis of complex social psychological issues. American Journal of Community Psychology, 53(1–2), 13–24. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10464-013-9611-5
Bogomolov, A. I. (2025). The evolution of the Faustian myth in Western European culture of the XVII–XVIII centuries. Ideas and Ideals, 17(2.2), 423–437. https://doi.org/10.17212/2075-0862-2025-17.2.2-423-437
Botta, F. (2019). Mythologies of demographic rejuvenationism: A causal layered analysis. Futures, 107, 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2018.11.002
Boyd, R., & Richerson, P. J. (2005). The origin and evolution of cultures. Oxford University Press.
Bregadze, K. (2023). Interpretation of the text in the conditions of ideological discourse: Goethe’s Faust in Soviet Georgian German studies. Text and Interpretation, 4. https://doi.org/10.55804/jtsu-2960-9461-2023-4
Breen, L. J., Dzidic, P. L., & Bishop, B. J. (2015). Causal layered analysis. In Oxford handbook of methods in positive psychology (pp. 103–110). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/med:psych/9780190243654.003.0011
Bryden, I. (2020). Tennyson and the return of King Arthur. In The Oxford handbook of Victorian literary culture. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199669509.013.39
Bürgel, J. C. (1988). The feather of Simurgh: The “licit magic” of the arts in medieval Islam. New York University Press.
Bussey, M. (2014). Causal layered analysis: Towards a theory of the multiple. Foresight and STI Governance, 8(2), 66–75. https://doi.org/10.17323/1995-459x.2014.1.66.75
Camrass, K. (2022). Regenerative urbanism: A causal layered analysis. Foresight, 24(5), 638–649. https://doi.org/10.1108/fs-11-2021-0227
Connolly, T. (2025). Fear of the future: Causal layered analysis and narrative foresight versus conspiracy theories. World Futures, 81, 579–592. https://doi.org/10.1080/02604027.2025.2569012
Cowart, T. (2022). CLA 3.0 and situational metaphor: Refining the fourth layer. Journal of Futures Studies, 26(4), 1–14. https://doi.org/10.6531/JFS.202206_26(4).0001
Davis, D. (Trans.). (2024). Shahnameh: The Persian book of kings (Rev. ed.). Penguin Classics.
Di Stefano, G., & Dalpiaz, E. (2018). A universe of stories: Mobilizing narrative practices during transformative change. Strategic Management Journal, 39(3), 664–696. https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2730
Erll, A. (2019). Odyssean travels: The migration of narrative form (Homer – Lamb – Joyce). In Narrative in culture (pp. 279–300). De Gruyter. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110654370-014
Fernández-Figares, J. M. (2019). Goethe’s Faust and the tragedy of modernity (pp. 41–61).
Ford, A. (2018). Simulating systems with fast and slow dynamics: Lessons from the electric power industry. System Dynamics Review, 34(1–2), 222–254. https://doi.org/10.1002/sdr.1595
Foroughi, H. (2020). Collective memories as a vehicle of fantasy and identification: Founding stories retold. Organization Studies, 41(10), 1347–1367. https://doi.org/10.1177/0170840619844286
Galtung, J., & Inayatullah, S. (Eds.). (1997). Macrohistory and macrohistorians: Perspectives on individual, social, and civilizational change. Praeger.
Ghahfarokhi, M. A., Mohaghar, A., & Saghafi, F. (2018). The futures of the University of Tehran using causal layered analysis. Foresight, 20(4), 393–410. https://doi.org/10.1108/fs-01-2018-0001
Haigh, M. (2016). Fostering deeper critical inquiry with causal layered analysis. Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 40(2), 164–181. https://doi.org/10.1080/03098265.2016.1141185
Harding, D. J., Dobson, C. C., Wyse, J. J. B., & Morenoff, J. D. (2017). Narrative change, narrative stability, and structural constraint: The case of prisoner reentry narratives. American Journal of Cultural Sociology, 5(3), 261–304. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41290-016-0004-8
Hase, J. (2021). Repetition, adaptation, institutionalization — How the narratives of political communities change. Ethnicities, 21(4), 684–705. https://doi.org/10.1177/1468796820987311
Henrich, J., Boyd, R., & Richerson, P. J. (2008). Five misunderstandings about cultural evolution. Human Nature, 19(2), 119–137. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12110-008-9037-1
Hoyer, D., Bennett, J. S., Reddish, J., Holder, S., Howard, R., Benam, M., Levine, J., Ludlow, F., Feinman, G. M., & Turchin, P. (2023). Navigating polycrisis: Long-run socio-cultural factors shape response to changing climate. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 378, 20220402. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2022.0402
Inayatullah, S. (1998a). Causal layered analysis: Poststructuralism as method. Futures, 30(8), 815–829. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0016-3287(98)00086-x
Inayatullah, S. (1998b). Macrohistory and futures studies. Futures, 30(4), 381–394. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0016-3287(98)00043-3
Inayatullah, S. (2002). Understanding Sarkar: The Indian episteme, macrohistory and transformative knowledge. Brill.
Inayatullah, S. (2008). Six pillars: Futures thinking for transforming. Foresight, 10(1), 4–21. https://doi.org/10.1108/14636680810855991
Inayatullah, S., & Milojević, I. (Eds.). (2015). CLA 2.0: Transformative research in theory and practice. Tamkang University Press.
Inayatullah, S., Milojević, I., & Sweeney, J. A. (Eds.). (2016). Special issue on metaphors and futures. Futures, 84, 1–162.
Inayatullah, S., Paine, E., & Scharmer, O. (2022). The navigation system, the planetary gardener, and the prism. Journal of Awareness-Based Systems Change, 2(2). https://doi.org/10.47061/jasc.v2i2.5047
Irwin, Z. T., & Redenius, C. M. (1984). William Irwin Thompson, the utopian tradition and American transcendentalism. Canadian Review of American Studies, 15(3), 271–286. https://doi.org/10.3138/cras-015-03-03
Jabbari, A. (2022). Review of K. L. Schwartz, Remapping Persian literary history, 1700–1900. International Journal of Persian Literature, 7, 151–156. https://doi.org/10.5325/intejperslite.7.0151
Kaboli, S. A., & Tapio, P. (2017). How late-modern nomads imagine tomorrow? A causal layered analysis practice to explore the images of the future of young adults. Futures, 96, 32–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2017.11.004
Kawai, T., Fahlbusch, J. T., Dienel, H., Renn, O., & Renn, R. (2022). Narratives for personal and collective transformations. Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 36(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1080/13511610.2022.2137108
Ketonen-Oksi, S. (2018). Creating a shared narrative: The use of causal layered analysis to explore value co-creation in a novel service ecosystem. European Journal of Futures Research, 6(1), 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40309-018-0135-y
Khaleghi-Motlagh, D. (2010). Notes on the Shahnameh (Vols. 1–4). Persian Heritage Foundation.
Khalegdadi, A., Mandegar, A., & Khazaivafa, M. (2025). A literary analysis of lyric elements in Nezami’s poem Khosrow and Shirin. Treasury of Persian Language and Literature. https://doi.org/10.61838/jtpll.154
Khouzani, H. R., Maleki, M., Zackery, A., Mazloumi, E., Jalilzadeh, M., & Sahebzadeh, M. (2024). Futures of gastric cancer: The fundamental level of prevention in health promotion using causal layered analysis. Heliyon, 10, e40437. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e40437
Kim, S., Connerton, T. P., & Park, C. (2021). Exploring the impact of technological disruptions in the automotive retail: A futures studies and systems thinking approach based on causal layered analysis and causal loop diagram. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 172, 121024. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2021.121024
Laan, J. M. van der, & Weeks, A. (Eds.). (2013). The Faustian century: German literature and culture in the age of Luther and Faustus. Camden House.
Lazard, G. (1975). The rise of the New Persian language. In R. N. Frye (Ed.), The Cambridge history of Iran: Vol. 4. The period from the Arab invasion to the Saljuqs (pp. 595–632). Cambridge University Press.
Li, R., Wang, H., & Li, Y. (2023). Learning slow and fast system dynamics via automatic separation of time scales. In Proceedings of the 29th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining. ACM. https://doi.org/10.1145/3580305.3599858
Losensky, P. (2003). The equal of heaven’s vault: The design of Naẓīrī’s reception of Bābā Fighānī. Iranian Studies, 36(3), 339–359. https://doi.org/10.1080/00210860308702244
MacGill, V. (2015). Unravelling the myth/metaphor layer in causal layered analysis. Journal of Futures Studies, 20(1), 55–67. https://doi.org/10.6531/jfs.2015.20(1).a55
Mancoff, D. N. (1995). The return of King Arthur: The legend through Victorian eyes. Harry N. Abrams.
Meisami, J. S. (1987). Medieval Persian court poetry. Princeton University Press.
Milojević, I., & Inayatullah, S. (2015). Narrative foresight. Futures, 73, 151–162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2015.08.007
Morgan, D. (2002). Images of the future: A historical perspective. Futures, 34(9–10), 883–893. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0016-3287(02)00007-1
Morgan, D. (2015). The dialectic of utopian images of the future within the idea of progress. Futures, 66, 106–119. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2015.01.004
Mukherjee, A. (2025). RRR and Adipurush: Adaptation of the Ramayana in pan-Indian cinema and circulation of Hindu nationalism. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 12. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-025-05639-5
Ngo, Q., Hoang, V., & Van Hoa Tran, T. (2025). Integrating anticipatory governance and causal layered analysis. Futures & Foresight Science. https://doi.org/10.1002/ffo2.70001
O’Mahony, T., Luukkanen, J., Vehmas, J., & Kaivo-oja, J. (2023). Time to build a new practice of foresight for national economies? Ireland, and uncertain futures in forecasts and scenarios. Foresight, 25(5), 649–665. https://doi.org/10.1108/fs-10-2021-0191
Patomäki, H., & Steger, M. (2010). Social imaginaries and Big History: Towards a new planetary consciousness? Futures, 42(10), 1056–1063. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2010.08.004
Peltonen, T. (2018). Revisiting the sociological origins of organization theory: The forgotten legacy of Pitirim Sorokin. Edward Elgar. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781785368752.00008
Polak, F. (1973). The image of the future (E. Boulding, Trans. & Abr.). Elsevier.
Richard, M. (2018). Applying Sorokin’s typology (pp. 159–170). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351292641-12
Riedy, C. (2008). An integral extension of causal layered analysis. Futures, 40(2), 150–159. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2007.11.009
Rindova, V., & Martins, L. (2021). Futurescapes: Imagination and temporal reorganization in the design of strategic narratives. Strategic Organization, 20(1), 200–224. https://doi.org/10.1177/1476127021989787
Rival, L. (2021). Anthropocene and the dawn of a planetary civilization. Anthropology Today, 37(4). https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8322.12686
Rius-Ulldemolins, J., & Pizzi, A. (2021). Cultural policy regimes and arts councils: The longue durée perspective. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 28(1), 17–33. https://doi.org/10.1080/10286632.2021.1883597
Sarhaddi, F. (2020). Exploration of binary oppositions in Nizami’s romantic couplet poems in lyrical literature. Revista San Gregorio, 1(37), 195–207. https://doi.org/10.36097/rsan.v1i37.1282
Schwartz, K. L. (2020). Remapping Persian literary history, 1700–1900. Edinburgh University Press.
Scolozzi, R., & Villa, M. (2025). Contrasting futures in the Alps: Causal layered analysis of the discourses guiding territorial development. Geographies, 5(4), 76. https://doi.org/10.3390/geographies5040076
Segerstad, H. A. P. (1973). Review of The image of the future by F. Polak. Acta Sociologica, 16(4), 354–355. https://doi.org/10.1177/000169937301600410
Sharma, P. (2026). Rāmāyaṇa and Mahābhārata in the Deccan. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198939122.001.0001
Silva, F., Coward, F., Davies, K., Elliott, S., Jenkins, E., Newton, A. C., Riris, P., Vander Linden, M., Bates, J., Cantarello, E., Contreras, D. A., Crabtree, S. A., Crema, E. R., Edwards, M., Filatova, T., Fitzhugh, B., Fluck, H., Freeman, J., Klein Goldewijk, K., . . . Williams, A. (2022). Developing transdisciplinary approaches to sustainability challenges: The need to model socio-environmental systems in the longue durée. Sustainability, 14(16), 10234. https://doi.org/10.3390/su141610234
Singh, S., & Thakur, D. (2025). Reclaiming lost narratives: Cultural memory, historical transformation, and the quest for authenticity in Angami and Naga literature. Literary Voice, 25(1), 178–186. https://doi.org/10.59136/lv.2025.25.1.21
Sorokin, P. A. (2017). Social and cultural dynamics: A study of change in major systems of art, truth, ethics, law and social relationships. Routledge. (Original work published 1937–1941). https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315129433
Spencer, A., & Salvatico, Y. (2015). Re-imagining story: A new approach to CLA. In S. Inayatullah & I. Milojević (Eds.), CLA 2.0. Tamkang University Press.
Spennemann, D. H. R. (2023). Conceptualizing a methodology for cultural heritage futures. Heritage, 6(1), 548–566. https://doi.org/10.3390/heritage6010029
Talattof, K. (1997). Nizami’s unlikely heroines: A study of the characterizations of women in classical Persian literature. Iranian Studies, 30(3–4), 195–217. https://doi.org/10.1080/00210869708701866
Talebian, S., & Talebian, H. (2018). The application of causal layered analysis to understand the present conditions and possible futures of media and politics in Iran. European Journal of Futures Research, 6(1), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40309-018-0137-9
Targowski, A. (2022). The ISCSC celebrates the 130th birth anniversary of Pitirim A. Sorokin. Heritage. https://doi.org/10.31119/hrtg.2022.1.3
Thompson, W. I. (1971). At the edge of history: Speculations on the transformation of culture. Harper & Row.
Thompson, W. I. (1981). The time falling bodies take to light: Mythology, sexuality and the origins of culture. St. Martin’s Press.
Tomasso, V. (2023). Nostalgias for Homer in Greek literature of the Roman Empire. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003378082
Vaara, E., Sonenshein, S., & Boje, D. (2016). Narratives as sources of stability and change in organizations. Academy of Management Annals, 10(1), 495–560. https://doi.org/10.1080/19416520.2016.1120963
van der Helm, R. (2005). The future according to Frederik Lodewijk Polak: Finding the roots of contemporary futures studies. Futures, 37(6), 505–519. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2004.10.017
Van Hoa Tran, T., & Ngo, Q. (2025). Reimagining digital labour futures in Vietnam. Futures & Foresight Science. https://doi.org/10.1002/ffo2.70027
Vanina, E. (2022). Modernization of the sacred: Two Ramayana novels (a historian’s view). Orientalistica, 5(2), 243–264. https://doi.org/10.31696/2618-7043-2022-5-2-243-264
Wahab, A. (2024). Two decades of causal layered analysis: A bibliometric analysis and review (2000–2022). World Futures Review, 16(2), 220–243. https://doi.org/10.1177/19467567241249712
Wallis, E. (2022). The once and future story. Reinvention: An International Journal of Undergraduate Research, 15(S1). https://doi.org/10.31273/reinvention.v15is1.872
Watson, C. (2009). Futures narratives, possible worlds, big stories: Causal layered analysis and the problems of youth. Sociological Research Online, 14(5), 231–242. https://doi.org/10.5153/sro.1969
Zuzánek, J. (2020). Pitirim Sorokin: At the crossroad of ideational and sensate cultures (pp. 177–188). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315619170-23
Persian primary sources
Ferdowsi, A. (2010). Shāhnāmeh [The book of kings] (Dj. Khaleghi-Motlagh, Ed.). Persian Heritage Foundation. (Original work composed c. 1010)
Nezāmi Ganjavi. (2003). Khosrow o Shirin [Khosrow and Shirin] (B. Sarvatian, Ed.). Amir Kabir. (Original work composed 1180)
Vahshi Bāfqi. (2010). Farhād o Shirin [Farhad and Shirin]. In Divān-e Vahshi Bāfqi [The collected poems of Vahshi Bafqi] (H. Nakhaei, Ed.). Amir Kabir. (Original work composed 16th century)
Vesāl Shirāzi. (1999). Takmile-ye Farhād o Shirin [The completion of Farhad and Shirin] (M. Vahid Dastgerdi, Ed.). Asātir. (Original work composed 19th century)
Sāber Kermāni. (2002). Tatemme-ye Farhād o Shirin [The continuation of Farhad and Shirin]. Sāye. (Original work composed late 19th century)